Commentary

 

Homeland Security
By Sikivu Hutchinson


One of the most pungent gallows humor quips on the Katrina disaster surmised that the federal response to the hurricane victims might not have been so criminally slow if Natalee Holloway had been discovered in New Orleans. In that scenario, the cavalry would have descended, homeland security would have been restored and Bush’s malign neglect would have been aimed at a less conspicuous target. Images of black women and children fighting for basic human dignity and accountability were some of the most anguishing scenes to come out of the disaster footage. This graphic display of black suffering, of the bankruptcy of American domestic policy, flickered on the global screen for a brief moment then receded into a swirl of white supremacist bromides. The female face of Katrina’s devastation, that of women and children who were wrenched, not just from single family homes, but from row houses, multifamily units and homeless shelters, underscored the iron link between black femininity and urban poverty. As with the Natalee Holloway scenario, some black observers speculated that had the world been turned inside out and blond white children and their mothers been depicted roaming water-logged streets or crammed into the filth of the Superdome for days on end there would have been a seismic shift in the terms of national debate on poverty and social welfare. The class currency or inherent capital that whiteness and white skin privilege confers would have surely preempted the ensuing right wing debate on the dispossessed hurricane victims’ lack of self-sufficiency and bootstraps rugged individualism. For graphic though the Katrina images were mainstream perceptions of black cultural pathology remained firmly in place. Despite all of its professed unease over the “third world” conditions exposed and exacerbated by the Katrina damage, white middle America maintained its belief in the victims’ complicity in the city’s social breakdown, and promptly recovered from its voyage to “sub-Saharan Africa” cum New Orleans, in due time.

Racist Katrina propaganda was fueled in part by the debased black female body, for, what real mother, what true keeper of home and hearth, would allow her children to be trotted out in sub-Dickensian squalor on national TV? The debased black female body has always existed in the interstice of public and private space. While the Cult of True Womanhood and Domesticity formed the basis for early models of white femininity, black women have historically been represented as hypersexual Jezebels or asexual mammy figures. Be she hypersexualized as a man-eating emasculating slut or hyper-domesticated (and hence stripped of femininity) as serviceable domestic/helpmate to white families, the black female body fulfilled a very specific role in the maintenance of white domesticity and national security. During the post World War II era the federal emphasis on facilitating white working and lower middle class access to the American dream via such New Deal social entitlements as FHA mortgage loans and the GI Bill led to the rise of the segregated white suburb and the elevation of the white nuclear family as national ideal. Excluded from the generous economic and social welfare opportunities afforded by the FHA and the GI Bill, African Americans were brutally dispossessed of this postwar inheritance.

Indeed, the “moribund” kitchens of the feminine mystique owe their daunting vacuity to this inheritance of white entitlement. While white middle class women promoted a second wave feminism defined by liberation from the confines of nuclear domesticity, black women and other women of color scrubbed the floors, drove the buses, swept the trash, and cleaned the cafeteria toilets of a prosperous America steeped in a culture of affirmative action for whites. This revolution of suburban manifest destiny is largely responsible for the vast differences in family wealth and capital that exist between whites and African Americans. Now more than ever before, in a climate in which defined benefit plans, wages, and health care access have declined, the house of imprisonment for so many white women is literally the bedrock of middle class economic sustainability. In Los Angeles County, the affordability index (which measures the number of potential homebuyers who can afford a single family home) hovers in the lowly 20% range, and many families of color are increasingly being priced out of middle class communities in traditionally African American areas like Leimert Park and Inglewood. The billions of dollars in home equity that this residential “wage of whiteness” has conferred on average white homeowners belie the oft-stated claim that class has eclipsed race as the most significant factor in determining social advantage and disadvantage.

more commentary-->